Mystery Costume – Who am I?

Mister Rogers Costume

This is a photo of my family’s Halloween costume.  My husband had shingles last Halloween so we had to postpone our dress up day.  Today, we went to a birthday party where costumes were encouraged so we pulled out our outfits.

Can any of you guess who we were?  $5 Amazon gift card to the first person to guess all three characters correctly.  No cheating (don’t Google for help) and none of my friends who were at the party today are eligible!  If ya’ll like it I’ll share more of the costume details with you later.

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
About Ashley

Ashley is very happily married and the mother to a beautiful little girl, and she is the main voice behind Embracing Beauty.


  1. I’m going to go with a geisha, a postman/deliveryman and Mr Rogers.

  2. Sara Nicole Beaston says

    mister rogers, mr mcfeely, lady aberlin

  3. angelgenius27 says

    I see someone already guessed….but I have to say these costumes are absolutely great! How creative! I grew up watching mr. rogers!

    • AshleyWalkup says

      Oh, thank you! I didn’t watch him growing up but I watch him every day now. The reruns of his show are all that my daughter wants to watch. ….and I’m okay with that, I like him too! 🙂

  4. Jodi Hoppe Wresh says

    mr fred rogers, lady aberlin, mr mcfeely and puppet punch Judy

    • AshleyWalkup says

      Very, very close! You’ve got them all except the puppet which is Lady Elaine Fairchild from Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood. They do have quite the likeness though!

  5. How creative! Great family costumes! I couldn’t figure it out, but as soon as I saw the answer in the comments, I was like, “Oh, yeah, I see it now!” 🙂

    • AshleyWalkup says

      Yea, I probably didn’t help you out any. They look in character and I just look like a lady in an outdated polyester dress. 🙂

  6. Lynda Self says

    That’s so cute! Except for the doll (puppet), which has always been a little creepy.

  7. Love the costumes! That was one of my two favorite shows growing up. The other being Today’s Special. It must have been fun putting those together.

  8. I wouldn’t have guessed but your munchkin looks adorable!

Speak Your Mind